Finding a safe and welcoming neighborhood is a top priority for many prospective homebuyers. 

Fort Myers, with its blend of vibrant communities and serene landscapes, offers a variety of safe neighborhoods that cater to diverse lifestyles. 

From bustling urban areas to tranquil suburban retreats, Fort Myers has it all. Today, we;’’ explore the safest neighborhoods in Fort Myers, providing you with valuable insights to help you find the perfect place to call home. 

Whether you are looking for homes for sale in Fort Myers or seeking advice from a local realtor in Fort Myers, this guide will help you navigate your options.

What to expect from Fort Myers

Fort Myers is not only known for its beautiful beaches and rich history but also for its friendly communities and safe living environments. 

Prospective homebuyers will find a range of properties, from affordable homes in Fort Myers to luxury estates, each located in neighborhoods with low crime rates and excellent amenities. 

This comprehensive guide highlights the best areas to consider, ensuring you can make an informed decision about your next home purchase.

Whether you’re interested in homes under $250,000 in Fort Myers or looking for upscale options, you’ll discover why so many people choose to settle down in this charming Florida city.

So, is Fort Myers a safe place to live?

Yes, Fort Myers is considered a safe place to live. Various neighborhoods within the city offer low crime rates, community-oriented living, and excellent amenities, making them ideal for families, retirees, and young professionals alike. Here are some of the safest neighborhoods in Fort Myers:

7 Safe & Desirable Neighbourhoods in Fort Myers

1. Iona

Iona is a picturesque neighborhood nestled near the Caloosahatchee River and San Carlos Bay. 

Known for its blend of urban and suburban vibes, Iona offers residents a tranquil environment with convenient access to beaches and outdoor activities. 

The area boasts low crime rates and a variety of high-end gated communities such as Gulf Harbour Yacht & Country Club. 

Homes here range from luxurious estates to more affordable options, making it suitable for a range of budgets. 

Local attractions include Norman Love Confections, Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster Bar, and various outdoor recreational activities like boating and fishing near the Port Sanibel Marina. 

If you’re looking for affordable homes in Fort Myers, Iona provides a mix of options that can cater to different lifestyle needs.

2. McGregor

McGregor is one of Fort Myers’ most historic and charming neighborhoods. Known for its iconic palm-lined streets and proximity to Downtown Fort Myers, McGregor offers a mix of waterfront properties and condominiums. 

The neighborhood is named after McGregor Boulevard, a main thoroughfare that provides easy access to various parts of the city. 

Residents enjoy the neighborhood’s rich history, with landmarks like the Edison and Ford Winter Estates. 

McGregor also offers excellent dining options such as Cibo Fort Myers and quaint cafes like McGregor Cafe. 

For those who enjoy outdoor activities, the Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve is nearby, offering trails and wildlife viewing. 

Homes for sale in Fort Myers’ McGregor area range from historic homes to modern developments, providing options for various preferences and budgets.

3. Cypress Lake

Cypress Lake is a serene and well-maintained neighborhood popular among retirees and families. 

This area is known for its quiet atmosphere and attractive scenery. Cypress Lake offers a variety of housing options, including apartments, single-family homes, and gated communities. 

The neighborhood is home to highly-rated public schools and several parks, such as Lakes Park, which features man-made lakes, walking trails, and playgrounds. 

Another local favorite is Manatee Park, where residents can view manatees in their natural habitat. 

Cypress Lake Plaza provides convenient shopping and dining options, making it a well-rounded community for those seeking affordable homes in Fort Myers.

4. Pelican Preserve

Pelican Preserve is a gated community designed for active adults, offering a safe and engaging environment. 

This neighborhood features a variety of amenities, including a championship golf course, fitness center, and miles of walking trails. 

Pelican Preserve emphasizes an active lifestyle with numerous social clubs and activities available to residents. 

Homes here range from luxurious single-family homes to more affordable condos, catering to different budget levels. 

The community’s well-maintained landscapes and tranquil setting make it an ideal choice for retirees and those seeking a vibrant, community-oriented lifestyle.

5. Whiskey Creek

Whiskey Creek is a desirable neighborhood known for its safety, beautiful homes, and family-friendly atmosphere. 

This area features a mix of well-maintained single-family homes and condominiums. Residents benefit from excellent schools, parks, and recreational facilities. 

The neighborhood’s central location provides easy access to shopping, dining, and entertainment options in Fort Myers. 

Whiskey Creek is also home to the Whiskey Creek Country Club, offering golf and social activities for residents. 

With homes under $250,000 in Fort Myers, Whiskey Creek provides affordable yet high-quality living options.

6. Gateway

Gateway is a master-planned community offering a blend of residential, commercial, and recreational spaces. 

Known for its safety and family-friendly environment, Gateway features a variety of amenities, including parks, sports fields, and a golf course. 

The community is designed to provide all necessary amenities within a short distance, making it convenient for residents. 

Housing options range from affordable single-family homes to more upscale properties, catering to different budget levels. 

Gateway’s excellent schools and well-maintained facilities make it a popular choice for families looking for homes for sale in Fort Myers.

7. Colonial Country Club

Colonial Country Club is a gated community that offers a luxurious lifestyle with a focus on safety and amenities. 

The neighborhood features a championship golf course, tennis courts, and a clubhouse with dining and fitness facilities. 

Residents enjoy a high standard of living in a secure environment. Colonial Country Club provides a range of housing options, from condos to spacious single-family homes, accommodating various budget levels. 

The community’s well-maintained landscapes and active social scene make it an attractive option for those seeking a blend of luxury and community living in Fort Myers.

Search for Affordable Homes in Colonial Country Club, Fort Myers, FL